Skip to main content

Police barricades fail to stop objects at Kolkata student bookstalls

Kolkata Police’s barricades failed to stop objects being thrown between rival ABVP and SFI bookstalls, and College Street was closed to traffic and pedestrians.

By India Wire Desk, Wire Desk2 min read2 sources
ShareWhatsAppX

Kolkata Police used steel barricades to separate ABVP and SFI bookstalls on College Street on Wednesday, but stones, firecrackers, eggs and water bottles were thrown during the confrontation. Police said nobody was critically injured and no arrests had been made by 7 pm; vehicular and pedestrian movement was suspended.

What happened

The SFI had permission for a temporary bookstall, according to a senior police officer quoted by Hindustan Times. The officer said ABVP members arrived around noon and tried to break through the barricades. Police then permitted the ABVP to operate a similar stall on the other side.

The Hindu reports that the ABVP stall was selling nationalist literature in front of the SFI’s planned three-day mini book fair of leftist and progressive writing. The confrontation continued despite the police contingent and barricades. SFI left College Street by 7 pm, according to Hindustan Times.

What we can verify

Both outlets independently establish that ABVP and SFI members clashed over rival bookstalls and that police intervened. Hindustan Times establishes the objects thrown, the road closure and the absence of arrests by 7 pm through named-event reporting and an on-duty police officer’s account.

The reports do not establish who threw the first object, how many people participated or the full extent of injuries and property damage. Police said there were no critical injuries; that does not provide a count of minor injuries.

The verified public-order failure is narrower than the competing political claims: the police arrangements did not prevent projectiles or keep College Street open. Kolkata Police were responsible for security at the spot. Neither report contains an independent assessment of their handling.

What each side says

The senior police officer said, “The SFI was given permission to set up a temporary stall and elaborate security arrangements were made to maintain law and order.” The same officer said police had instructions to control the situation without using force.

SFI members alleged that stones, eggs and crackers were thrown at them despite the police presence. ABVP members said SFI members hurled similar objects. Those competing accusations remain unresolved in the reporting.

Bengal BJP president Samik Bhattacharya said ABVP was not the BJP’s student front and that the two organisations would settle the issue themselves. Neither report includes a response from the West Bengal government or the Trinamool Congress about Wednesday’s policing.

What it means for people

Residents, shopkeepers, students and commuters lost access to College Street while both vehicular and pedestrian movement was suspended. Stones and firecrackers also created a safety risk even though police reported no critical injuries.

The immediate accountability question concerns Kolkata Police’s operational plan: why barricades and a large contingent could not prevent objects being thrown or keep the street open. The reports do not say whether there will be a review, who authorised the road closure or what will change to protect peaceful bookselling and public access if the stalls return.

  • West Bengal
  • student safety
  • policing

Sources

  1. The Hindu — SFI, ABVP clash over rival bookstalls on Kolkata's College Street(opens in a new tab)thehindu.com
  2. Hindustan Times — ABVP, SFI clash over bookstall in Kolkata’s College Street(opens in a new tab)hindustantimes.com

Spotted a mistake, or know something about this story? Send a correction or tip. Corrections are appended, never silently overwritten.

Keep reading